A new study from the University of Chicago establishes that Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease
(GERD) may contribute to pediatric swallowing dysfunction.
The study further suggests that GERD treatment may improve
the swallowing function in distress.
Infant swallowing is a highly
coordinated process. In order for an infant to swallow,
intact sensorimotor reflexes must be integrated at the
brainstem level. Any changes in this sequence can lead to
difficulty in feeding and swallowing which may ultimately
lead to aspiration. If an infant experiences swallowing
problems and they are untreated, then the child is at risk
for malnutrition, dehydration, and respiratory problems.
There are a variety of causes
for infant swallowing problems including GERD. GERD is
extremely common, affecting some 5-8 percent of the
pediatric population. GERD is defined as a backflow of acid
from the stomach into the swallowing tube or esophagus.
Common symptoms of GERD include vomiting, regurgitation,
pain and excessive crying or constant fussiness. Symptoms
can range from mild to life-threatening.
The relationship between GERD,
microaspiration, and respiratory diseases is an accepted and
frequently described scenario in medical literature. Despite
this, the scientific study of such changes, by which a
neurologically-intact larynx, which should protect the lower
airway, can allow microaspiration to occur, is rarely
discussed.
A new study attempts to address
that relationship in the study, "Improved Infant Swallowing
after GERD Treatment: A Function of Improved Laryngeal
Sensation?" The authors are Dana L. Suskind MD, Penny
Huddleston M.A., CCC-SLP, Fuad M. Baroody MD, and Donald C.
Liu MD PhD all from the University of Chicago; Dana M.
Thompson MD from the Division of Pediatric Otolaryngology,
Mayo Clinic and Mayo Eugenio Litta Children's Hospital; and
Martha Gulati MD with the Department of Preventive Medicine
and Cardiology, Northwestern University. Their findings will
be presented at the 21st annual meeting of the American
Society of Pediatric Otolaryngology, being held May 20-22,
2006, at the Hyatt Regency Hotel in Chicago, IL.
Methodology: The authors
hypothesized that laryngopharyngeal reflux (LPR) has a
negative impact on laryngopharyngeal sensation with
resulting microaspiration/penetration in infants and
children, and that reflux treatment will have a positive
impact on swallowing function in these patients. A review of
28 patient records (21 males, seven females)
neurologically-intact infants and children (e.g. no evidence
of cerebral palsy, seizures, etc.), ranging in age from one
to thirty-two months, from two different tertiary-care
children's hospitals with evidence of gross as well as
micro-aspiration, swallowing dysfunction, and LPR, was made.
Each child underwent either medical or surgical intervention
for control of their GERD. The patients had their swallow
function and laryngeal sensitivity evaluated before and
after treatment of gastroesophageal reflux.
LPR was treated either with a
course of anti-reflux medication or anti-reflux surgery as
guided by the treating physician. A repeat Videofluoroscopic
Swallow Study (VSS) or Flexible Endoscopic Evaluation of
Swallowing and Sensation Testing (FEESST) was performed at
the end of treatment. During the VSS, the infants were
positioned in a typical feeding position consistent with
their age and development. They were given a variety of food
consistencies (thin liquid, thick liquid, puree, soft solid,
hard solid) injected with barium. The study assessed all
three phases of the swallow from the oral preparatory phase,
oral initiation phase, and the pharyngeal phase. FEESST is
an alternative test to the X-ray test of swallowing that
uses a specifically designed endoscope in order to assess
both the sensory and motor components of swallowing.
Results: Some 28 patients
presented with clinical evidence of dysphagia. There were
seven females and 21 males with ages ranging from four to 42
weeks at the time of initial evaluation (not adjusted for
prematurity), with a median age of 23.6 weeks. A history of
prematurity was the predominant medical issue in 8/11 from
institution #1 and 7/17 from institution #2 with 54 percent
of the patients overall being born before 37 weeks
gestation. All patients had clinical evidence of
gastroesophageal reflux disease which was supported with
adjunctive tests; five had an abnormal both barium swallow
and pH probe, thirteen had an abnormal barium swallow and
two had an abnormal pH probe. All study participants
demonstrated varying degrees of swallow dysfunction on VSS
and FEESST.
Repeat swallow evaluation was performed from three to 78.1
weeks post intervention with a median of 18 weeks. Whereas
the pre treatment assessment yielded 23/28 (82 percent)
patients with aspiration, the post-treatment assessment only
showed 4/28 (14 percent) patients still aspirating, a
significant reduction. Correlating with their improved
swallowing, all patients who underwent FEESST testing
demonstrated a significant reduction in the sensory
threshold required to elicit the LPR reflex indicating
improved sensation level. In addition, those who underwent
VSS demonstrated significant improvement in both pharyngeal
impairment scores and swallow scores with a significant
reduction, displaying a qualitative equivalent of a change
from mild-moderate pharyngeal impairment to basically normal
pharyngeal function and from moderate swallowing impairment
to mild swallowing impairment. The researchers found that 26
of 28 patients being able to resume age-appropriate,
unrestricted diets; these 26 included two of the four who
were unable to tolerate any type of oral intake prior to
treatment.
Conclusion: The study authors
acknowledge that swallowing function improves with
maturation, but they speculate that it could also be related
to better control of GERD. Their study suggests that LPR may
lead to impaired laryngeal sensation with resultant
dysphagia and microaspiration. It further suggests that
treatment of acid reflux with anti-reflux medication or
surgery can reverse the deleterious changes and thus improve
swallowing in these children. |